← All insights
GEO Fundamentals8 January 20265 min read

Why being on page one of Google no longer matters as much as it did

Page one used to be the only game in town. With AI Overviews now sitting above the organic results, the rules have changed — and the brands clinging to old metrics are starting to feel it.

AE
Aether Editorial
Aether Editorial

For most of the last decade, the obsession was clear: rank in the top three organic results, win the click. Page one was the goal because the top of page one is where the eyeballs landed.

That's still partially true. But over the last eighteen months, Google has fundamentally changed what page one looks like.

For the majority of commercial queries — the questions buyers ask when they're trying to choose a service or product — Google now generates an AI Overview at the top of the results. The Overview answers the question directly, names a small set of recommended brands, and pushes the ten organic links well below the fold. Click-through to those organic links has dropped sharply in tracked categories.

If you are the brand named in the AI Overview, the visit is yours. If you are not, you've been demoted by an algorithm to a footnote — even if you ranked second on the page yesterday.

This is not the end of SEO. Authority and content quality still matter, and many of the signals that earn organic rankings also feed into AI Overview eligibility. But the optimisation target has shifted. The brands quietly winning in 2026 are not the ones with the longest list of keywords; they are the ones AI engines consistently cite by name.

For some categories the impact is staggering. We track buyer-intent queries in UK professional services where the AI Overview now serves more than 60 per cent of total impressions, and the named brand inside it receives the lion's share of the attention. The number-two organic result, four lines below, gets the scraps.

If you are still measuring success only by Google position, you are measuring last decade's game. The new question is simpler: when AI answers, does it name you?

Want to know where AI cites your competitors instead of you?

Free 60-second audit. We’ll send a personalised visibility report within 24 hours.